UPDATES
.

Resource Mobilisation: Challenges and Way Forward | UPSC Notes

  • Home
  • Resource Mobilisation: Challenges and Way Forward | UPSC Notes
Shape Image One

Resource Mobilisation : Challenges and Way Forward

Resource mobilisation refers to the process through which the government raises financial resources to meet its developmental and welfare responsibilities. It includes not only taxation but also non-tax sources such as income from public services, public enterprises, public utilities, fees, dividends, user charges, disinvestment and borrowing. In the post-liberalisation period, India’s expenditure needs have increased due to welfare schemes, infrastructure requirements, defence needs, urbanisation and social sector commitments. However, mobilising adequate, stable and equitable resources remains a major challenge.

Challenges

  • Narrow tax base 
    • India’s tax base remains relatively narrow compared to the size of its population and economy. A large number of people remain outside the direct tax net due to low incomes, exemptions, informal employment and under-reporting of income. This limits the government’s ability to mobilise resources through income tax.
      • Only ~8 crore income tax filers in a country of 140 crore — extremely narrow base 
      • Large informal economy — estimated at 40–50% of GDP — largely outside tax net
      • Agricultural income exemption — constitutionally protected — excludes significant rural income
      • High threshold limits and generous deductions reduce effective taxpayer base
      • Self-employed and professional income significantly under-reported — weak third-party reporting
      • Tax-to-income ratio for the wealthy is disproportionately low — effective rates below statutory rates
  • Large informal sector 
    • A significant part of India’s economy operates in the informal sector.
    • Informal enterprises often maintain poor records, deal in cash and remain outside formal taxation systems. This makes it difficult for the government to assess income, track transactions and collect taxes effectively.
  • Tax evasion and avoidance 
    • Tax evasion through under-reporting of income, fake invoices, cash transactions, benami assets and misuse of exemptions reduces government revenue.
      • India’s black economy estimated at 20–25% of GDP — enormous untaxed resource pool
      • Cash transactions — particularly in real estate, gold, and informal trade — evade taxation
      • Benami property — assets held in fictitious names — conceals taxable wealth
      • Offshore tax evasion — undisclosed foreign assets, round-tripping through Mauritius, Singapore
      • Tax havens — shell companies in Cayman Islands, British Virgin Islands — used by wealthy Indians
      • Panama Papers and Pandora Papers — revealed scale of offshore wealth concealment
    • At the same time, tax avoidance through legal loopholes and aggressive tax planning also weakens revenue mobilisation.
  • Tax Expenditure — Revenue Foregone 
    • Tax exemptions, deductions, and concessions — collectively called tax expenditures — erode revenue base significantly 
      • Corporate tax exemptions benefit large companies
      • Personal income tax deductions — 80C, HRA, LTA — benefit primarily salaried middle class
      • Tax expenditures are rarely reviewed or evaluated — accumulated over decades without scrutiny
      • Represent opaque subsidy — equivalent fiscal cost to explicit subsidies but less visible
  • Dependence on indirect taxes
    • India has historically depended heavily on indirect taxes such as GST, excise and customs duties.
    • Indirect taxes are easier to collect but may be regressive because they affect both rich and poor consumers. Excessive dependence on indirect taxes can reduce equity in resource mobilisation.
  • GST related challenges
    • GST has improved indirect tax integration, but challenges remain in compliance, fake invoicing, input tax credit fraud, classification disputes, delayed refunds and technological difficulties for small businesses.
    • These issues affect the full revenue potential of GST. 
      • Input Tax Credit (ITC) fraud — fake invoices, circular trading — erodes GST revenue significantly 
      • Real estate, alcohol, petroleum outside GST — significant economic sectors untaxed under unified system 
  • Complexity of tax administration
    • Multiple rules, frequent changes, compliance burden and litigation make tax administration difficult.
    • This increases uncertainty for taxpayers and creates administrative costs for the government.
  • Weak property tax collection
    • Urban local bodies have large potential to raise revenue through property tax, user charges and municipal services.
    • However, outdated property records, undervaluation, political resistance, weak assessment and poor collection reduce local revenue mobilisation.
  • Underpricing of public services
    • Many public services such as water supply, electricity, public transport, irrigation and sanitation are often provided at highly subsidised rates or with poor recovery of user charges.
    • While subsidies may be needed for vulnerable sections, universal underpricing reduces the ability of public utilities to maintain and expand services.
  • Financial weakness of public utilities
    • Public utilities such as electricity distribution companies, water boards and transport corporations often suffer from losses due to low tariffs, theft, poor billing, inefficient operations and political interference.
    • This reduces their ability to generate internal resources and increases dependence on budgetary support.
    • Water Supply and Sanitation Utilities 
      • Urban water utilities are nearly universally loss-making
      • Water tariffs far below supply cost — covering only 20–30% of O&M expenses
      • Non-Revenue Water (NRW) — physical losses through leakage + commercial losses through theft and unbilled consumption — averaging 40–50% in Indian cities
      • No incentive for efficiency improvement — losses covered by municipal budget or state grants
      • Water — treated as a free public good rather than an economic resource — prevents revenue generation
      • Urban water utilities should be self-financing — in most Indian cities they are a fiscal drain
    • Transport Utilities — Railways and Urban Transport 
      • Indian Railways — world’s largest rail network — yet financially stressed
      • Passenger fares kept below cost — cross-subsidised by freight
      • Freight overpricing makes rail uncompetitive — industry shifts to road — reducing rail revenue
      • Operating ratio (expenditure as % of revenue) — above 95% — leaves virtually nothing for investment
      • Metro rail systems — huge capital investment, low fare revenue, operational losses — dependent on government support
      • Road transport corporations (state RTCs) — almost universally loss-making due to concessional fares
      • Public transport — meant to be a revenue-generating utility — is predominantly a fiscal liability
  • Limited returns from public assets
    • The government owns large amounts of land, buildings, minerals, spectrum, infrastructure and public enterprises.
    • However, poor asset management, encroachment, undervaluation and slow monetisation reduce the revenue potential of these assets.
    • Weak royalty and fee collection
      • Resources from minerals, forests, spectrum, ports and other public assets are not always fully realised.
      • Illegal mining, under-reporting, weak monitoring and poor pricing of natural resources reduce government revenue.
  • Challenges in disinvestment and asset monetisation
    • Disinvestment can help raise resources, but it faces political resistance, valuation concerns, market uncertainty, employee opposition and fear of loss of strategic control.
    • Therefore, disinvestment targets are often difficult to achieve.
    • Disinvestment — Chronic Underperformance 
      • Disinvestment targets are set ambitiously — missed chronically
      • Political resistance — trade unions, ministerial ownership, strategic sector arguments
      • Market timing challenges — PSU valuations low when fiscal need is high
      • Legal and procedural delays — court challenges, worker opposition
      • Bureaucratic reluctance — officials protective of ministry-controlled enterprises
      • Disinvestment proceeds — a one-time non-recurring resource — used for current expenditure rather than debt reduction
  • High dependence on borrowing
    • When tax and non-tax revenues are insufficient, the government depends on borrowing.
    • Borrowing can support development, but excessive borrowing increases debt burden and future interest payments, reducing fiscal flexibility.
  • Political Economy Constraints 
    • Resource mobilisation reforms are politically costly: 
      • Tax increases — electoral liability
      • User charge revision — seen as anti-poor
      • PSU privatisation — opposed by trade unions and ministries
      • Subsidy reduction — political suicide
    • Electoral cycle — governments avoid revenue mobilisation measures before elections
    • Populist competition among states — free electricity, water, transport — reduces utility revenue
    • Vested interests — wealthy tax evaders, PSU employees, subsidy beneficiaries — block reform
    • India’s democratic politics creates structural bias toward expenditure over revenue
  • Federal Fiscal Architecture Challenges 
    • Resource mobilisation is complicated by India’s federal structure:
      • Centre raises most taxes — states have most expenditure responsibilities
      • Vertical fiscal imbalance — states dependent on central transfers
      • States have limited independent revenue sources — land revenue, state excise, stamps
      • Horizontal imbalance — resource-rich states vs resource-poor states
    • Finance Commission devolution — states argue inadequate for their mandates
    • States compete in tax concessions to attract industry — race to the bottom in resource mobilisation
    • Local bodies — panchayats and urban local bodies — have virtually no independent resource mobilisation
  • Poor performance of some public enterprises
    • Some public sector enterprises continue to suffer from low productivity, overstaffing, outdated technology, weak competitiveness and operational losses.
    • Instead of contributing dividends or profits to the government, they may require financial support, thereby becoming a burden on public resources.
    • Dividend and Surplus from RBI and PSUs 
      • RBI dividend transfer to government — significant but variable — cannot be relied upon as stable resource
      • PSU dividends — declining as many PSUs are loss-making or under-performing
      • Profit-making PSUs — ONGC, Coal India, BHEL — under pressure to over-pay dividends — compromising investment
      • Financial sector PSUs — public sector banks — require recapitalisation rather than generating dividends
      • Resource mobilisation from public enterprise surpluses is inherently limited by PSU performance quality
    • Loss-Making Public Sector Undertakings 
      • A significant number of Central Public Sector Enterprises (CPSEs) are loss-making — draining rather than contributing to resources
      • Air India — accumulated losses of ₹70,000+ crore before privatisation
      • BSNL and MTNL — combined losses requiring massive recapitalisation
      • Instead of contributing revenue, loss-making PSUs require budget support and bailouts

Way Forward

  • Broadening the Direct Tax Base 
    • More individuals and enterprises should be brought into the formal tax system through better income reporting, use of digital transactions, data analytics and third-party information.
    • The focus should be on improving compliance rather than increasing tax rates.
      • Implement comprehensive income reporting — mandatory third-party reporting of all income streams to Income Tax Department
      • Use AI and big data analytics — cross-reference GST data, property registrations, vehicle purchases, travel records to detect under-reporting
      • Gradually bring agricultural income above a threshold into tax net — politically sensitive but fiscally necessary
      • Expand presumptive taxation schemes for small businesses and professionals — low compliance burden, wider coverage
      • Strengthen TDS (Tax Deducted at Source) and TCS (Tax Collected at Source)  mechanisms — widen scope to capture more informal sector transactions
      • Develop taxpayer segmentation — differentiated compliance strategies for large, medium, and small taxpayers
  • GST Reforms 
    • GST collections can be improved by checking fake invoicing, input tax credit fraud, classification disputes and under-reporting. 
      • Strengthen ITC fraud detection — AI-based invoice matching, real-time reconciliation
      • Bring petroleum, real estate, and electricity progressively under GST — expand tax base
      • Simplify compliance procedures for small businesses — reduce return filing burden
      • Strengthen GSTN technology infrastructure — eliminate technical glitches undermining compliance
      • Develop GST audit capacity — trained officers for risk-based scrutiny
  • Tackling Tax Evasion and Black Money 
    • Tax evasion through cash transactions, fake invoices, benami assets, under-reporting of income and misuse of exemptions should be checked through stronger enforcement, better information sharing and data-based tax administration. 
      • Strengthen implementation of Benami Transactions Prohibition Act — attach and auction benami properties
      • Strengthen foreign asset disclosure — automatic exchange of information under OECD frameworks
      • Expand financial intelligence units — coordinate between IT Department, ED, and banks
      • Promote cashless economy — digital transactions create audit trail, reduce cash-based evasion
      • Implement GAAR (General Anti-Avoidance Rules) effectively — prevent aggressive tax planning
      • Develop whistleblower reward scheme — incentivize reporting of large-scale tax evasion
  • Rationalising Tax Expenditures 
    • Conduct comprehensive tax expenditure review — publish annual revenue foregone statement with justification
    • Sunset unjustified corporate exemptions — sector-specific concessions beyond policy purpose
    • Rationalize personal income tax deductions — simplify, target toward genuinely developmental savings
    • Link tax incentives to measurable outcomes — R&D investment, employment generation, green investment
    • Move toward lower rates, broader base — reduce incentive for evasion while improving revenue
  • Strengthen property taxation
    • Urban local bodies should improve property tax collection through updated property records, GIS mapping, realistic valuation, digital payment systems and better enforcement.
    • This can significantly improve local resource mobilisation.
  • Improve user charges for public services
    • Public services such as water supply, sanitation, irrigation, public transport and municipal services should have reasonable user charges.
    • However, poor and vulnerable sections should be protected through targeted subsidies rather than universal underpricing.
      • Develop cost-reflective pricing roadmap for all public services — phased revision with social safeguards
      • Introduce income-based differential pricing — poor pay subsidised rates, non-poor pay cost-covering rates
      • Revise irrigation water charges — volumetric pricing with measurement infrastructure
      • Rationalize Railways passenger fares — eliminate cross-subsidization, introduce tiered pricing
      • Review university and hospital user charges — meaningful cost recovery from those who can afford
      • Develop independent regulatory framework for utility pricing — depoliticize tariff revision
  • Improve financial health of public utilities
    • Electricity distribution companies, water boards and transport corporations should improve billing, reduce theft and technical losses, revise tariffs rationally and improve operational efficiency.
    • This will reduce their dependence on budgetary support and help them generate internal resources.
  • Improve performance of public enterprises
    • Public enterprises should be made more efficient through professional management, better governance, technology upgradation and operational reforms.
    • Profitable public enterprises can contribute through dividends, surplus and reinvestment capacity.
  • Natural Resource and Asset Monetisation 
    • Royalty, licence fees, spectrum charges, mining revenues and forest-based revenues should be collected transparently.
      • Illegal mining, under-reporting and undervaluation of natural resources must be checked.
    • Government land, infrastructure assets, spectrum, minerals and other public assets should be used more efficiently.
    • Asset monetisation should be transparent, fairly valued and designed in a way that protects public interest.
      • Accelerate National Monetisation Pipeline (NMP) — roads, railways, airports, power transmission, pipelines
      • Ensure competitive bidding for all natural resource allocation — spectrum, coal, minerals, oil blocks
      • Develop government land asset registry — identify, value, and monetise underutilised public land
      • Promote Land Value Capture mechanisms — monetise appreciation in land value from public infrastructure investment
      • Revise mineral royalty rates — align with market values — particularly for coal, iron ore, bauxite
  • Undertake strategic disinvestment
    • Disinvestment can help mobilise resources where government ownership is not essential.
    • However, it should be based on transparent valuation, proper timing, protection of strategic interests and clear regulatory safeguards.
      • Implement new PSU policy — government presence only in strategic sectors (atomic energy, space, defence)
      • Complete strategic disinvestment pipeline 
      • Develop realistic disinvestment calendar — market-aligned timing, advance investor preparation
      • Establish Transaction Advisory Unit — professional team managing disinvestment process
      • Use disinvestment proceeds for debt reduction — not current expenditure — sustainable fiscal benefit
      • Promote employee stock ownership in privatised PSUs — manage workforce transition
  • Strengthen local government finances
    • Panchayats and urban local bodies should be empowered to raise their own resources through property tax, user charges, local fees and better collection systems.
    • This will reduce overdependence on grants and improve local accountability.
  • Encourage formalisation of the economy
    • Digital payments, GST integration, Udyam registration etc.. access can bring more economic activity into the formal system.
      • Accelerate GST-driven formalisation — make formal registration advantageous for small businesses
      • Strengthen social security for formal workers — incentivize registration over informality
      • Develop MSME formalisation support — credit, technology, market access for those joining formal economy
      • Promote digital payments ecosystem — UPI penetration in rural and semi-urban areas
      • Link government procurement to GST registration — formalization as prerequisite for government business
    • Formalisation improves both tax and non-tax resource mobilisation.
  • Make resource mobilisation equitable
    • The burden of resource mobilisation should not fall disproportionately on the poor.
    • Greater reliance should be placed on progressive taxation, better taxation of high-income groups, improved property taxation and targeted user charges.
  • Reforming Federal Resource Mobilisation 
    • Develop own revenue sources for states — property tax modernization, land value capture, state carbon taxes
    • Strengthen urban local body revenue — property tax, user charges, advertisement tax, land monetisation
    • Reform Finance Commission framework — reward states that improve own revenue mobilisation
    • Develop inter-state tax coordination — prevent harmful tax competition among states
    • Empower panchayats with revenue instruments — local service charges, market fees, minor forest produce
    • Implement property tax reform nationally — GIS-based assessment, market value-linked rates
  • Institutional and Capacity Building 
    • Modernize Income Tax and GST administration — technology-driven, risk-based, taxpayer-friendly
    • Develop dedicated resource mobilisation units in Finance Ministry and states
    • Build regulatory capacity for utility pricing — professional, independent, insulated from politics
    • Strengthen audit and enforcement — more officers, better training, reduced litigation backlog
    • Promote public financial management training — IRS, IAS, and state finance service officers
    • Develop research capacity on resource mobilisation — tax policy analysis, revenue forecasting

Resource mobilisation in India requires a broad approach that goes beyond taxation. The government must widen the tax base, improve compliance, strengthen GST, rationalise exemptions, improve income from public services, revive the financial health of public utilities and make better use of public assets. The aim should be to create a stable, fair and sustainable revenue base without hurting growth or welfare.

Sample Mains Questions

Q1. What is resource mobilisation? Explain its major sources in India.
(150 words, 10 marks)

Q2. Discuss the major challenges in resource mobilisation in India.
(250 words, 15 marks)

✍️ Curated by InclusiveIAS Editorial Team

At InclusiveIAS, our editorial team is led by experts who have successfully cleared multiple stages of the UPSC Civil Services Examination, including Mains and Interview. With deep insights into the demands of the exam, we focus on crafting content that is accurate, exam-relevant, and easy to grasp.

Whether it’s Polity, Current Affairs, GS papers, or Optional subjects, our notes are designed to:

  • Break down complex topics into simple, structured points

  • Align strictly with the UPSC syllabus and PYQ trends

  • Save your time by offering crisp yet comprehensive coverage

  • Help you score more with smart presentation, keywords, and examples

🟢 Every article, note, and test is not just written—but carefully edited to ensure it helps you study faster, revise better, and write answers like a topper.

Telegram Channel Links

InclusiveIAS

Answer Writing Group

Essay Writing Group

UPSC PRELIMS NOTES

Polity

International Relations

Environment

Economy

Science and Technology

Geography

History and Culture

Mapping

UPSC MAINS NOTES

General Studies - 4 (Ethics)

General Studies - 3

General Studies - 2

General Studies - 1